Team needs prior to the draft: OL, RB, TE, DL, LB
1st round pick (23rd overall): Evan Engram, WR/TE, Ole Miss
Standing at 6’3” and 235 pounds, Engram is certainly a talented player with tremendous ability. Running a 4.42 and showing off a 36” vertical at the NFL combine, his speed along with his athleticism make him a matchup nightmare. However, his inability to effectively block as well as his lack of height for his position makes me think he is more of a wide receiver. With four lethal weapons on the field, the Giants’ potential in the passing game is high. However, the Giants went for flash and flare and ignored evident holes on their O-line and in their running game. With offensive linemen Ryan Ramczyk and Cam Robinson on the board, along with running back Dalvin Cook, I certainly question this move—not to knock Engram, because he can be special, but to knock Jerry Reese for blatantly ignoring the Giants’ dire needs and going for the “sexy pick” instead. Hopefully, Engram can show off his speed, because Eli may not have that much time to get rid of the ball!
Scouting report via A.R. Smith Scouting
Engram is a super athletic four-year starter from Ole Miss. He has the speed and agility be a threat against all defenders on any area of the field. Engram has naturally soft hands and displays great concentration on hard catches but struggles mightily when asked to catch through contact. Defenders often are able to separate the ball with simple contact. Engram doesn’t use his size to box out defenders nor does display the toughness to out muscle defenders at the catch point. Engram isn’t a great route runner. He was able to rely on using his speed to run away from slower defenders at the college level. Ole Miss also did a great job putting him in position where he could combine his speed with natural leverage, such as running an out route vs. a defender lined up towards the inside. He needs to learn to break down and explode out his cuts using his natural burst rather than running round routes. Engram also struggled when contacted during his routes. Even the slightest shove will throw him off his path and he takes too long to regain balance and is sometimes eliminated from the whole play. Engram has the vertical ability to compete for the ball at the highest point but in limited opportunities he didn’t show enough consistency. As a blocker he shows good effort but he needs to learn to keep his head up and rely on his arms to make contact first in order to whiff less. He also needs to gain strength to be able to block NFL defenders. While he does a good job driving his legs, his base can be a bit wide initially giving him less balance. After the catch Engram relies on his speed rather than attempting to elude defenders in the open field or break tackles. Engram is a TE with a super high ceiling. Passing teams will be able to line him up at all receiver and TE positions effectively. He needs to gain strength as well as sharpen his route running to become a better player. He’s a high upside early 2nd rounder.
Who I would have taken: Ryan Ramczyk, OL, Wisconsin
2nd round pick (55th overall): Dalvin Tomlinson, DL, Alabama
This guy is impressive on and off the field. He was offered an academic scholarship to Harvard, but chose to play football at Alabama instead—a good decision. At 6’3” and 310 lbs., Tomlinson can certainly fill the starting defensive tackle position which is vacant due to Jonathan Hankins’ exit. I love any defensive player who comes out of Alabama; they’re the best of the best! Tomlinson’s strength and ability to stuff the run can really bolster the Giants’ front four. While they need a linebacker, it is certainly the next best option since Hankins left. He will not necessarily be an immediate starter, because he will need to compete with Jay Bromley and Michael Thomas, but I think he will beat them out and be very effective this season.
Who I would have taken: Zach Cunningham, LB, Vanderbilt
3rd round pick (87th overall): Davis Webb, QB, California
We really needed a quarterback, and thank goodness we took one—oh wait, we have one. He’s 36-years-old, not 42. Eli Manning has a solid 3 to 4 years left of being a very good quarterback. No, he isn’t Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers, but last season he threw for over 4,000 yards while completing 63% of his passes on 26 touchdowns and 16 interceptions. This is Eli Manning, a two-time Super Bowl champion who does not need to be replaced for another few years. There was absolutely no need to take a quarterback this early, especially since we needed a top tier running back in this class, and yet again we passed on it. Next year’s quarterback class is supposed to be loaded, and no matter how much potential Webb really has, I don’t know if he’s really the guy we can mold into a franchise quarterback. Plus, weren’t we supposed to resurrect Geno Smith’s career? I’m not saying Webb can’t be good, because he can be, but it is not the right place or time to have him join the team. And while Webb has a lot of arm strength, he struggles with accuracy—something that’s very concerning when your job is to be accurate.
Who I would have taken: D’Onta Foreman, RB, Texas
4th round pick (140th overall): Wayne Gallman, RB, Clemson
Gallman won the National Championship at Clemson and ran a 4.6 at the combine—pretty middle of the road for his position. He knows how to win, having played with NFL-caliber players and against NFL-caliber opponents at Clemson.
5th round pick (167th overall): Avery Moss, DE, Youngstown State
Scouts say that Moss reminds them of Robert Ayers, so essentially the guy could come in on first or second down to give JPP or Vernon a breather. Late round pick, so not much to lose here.
6th round pick (200th overall): Adam Bisnowaty, OL, Pitt
Reese finally realized he forgot that our biggest need was our offensive line. Good thing he realized this late.
Overall draft grade: C+
Overall, the Giants had a slightly underwhelming draft. They took talented guys, but really ignored most of their core needs, waiting until the 4th round to pick a running back, and until the 6th to take an offensive lineman. They were ranked 27th in offensive efficiency last season, so taking one offensive player who will play in the first three rounds is unacceptable. They absolutely should not have taken a quarterback unless he is as good as Eli right now, because the fact is, Eli is still playing well and the next guy in line is probably someone in the next couple of classes. Reese is banking on the hope that Erick Flowers will improve and not be as much of a liability as he was last season, as well as on the hope that Webb can be molded into the next franchise quarterback. Hopefully, they’ll get their guys ready for opening night, and I can’t wait for Giants football this fall!
DISCLAIMER: Scouting Report on Evan Engram was written by @AdemiSmithScout. Share your feedback with him on twitter.
Image via http://nypost.com/2017/04/27/giants-snare-ole-miss-pass-catching-tight-end-with-23rd-pick/
About Me: I’m Spencer Alexander Zied, a 12th grader from New York, New York. I love to play basketball and tennis, and am a big fan of the Knicks, Giants and the Yankees. I’m also a big fan of First Take and Sportscenter on ESPN. You can email me at firstname.lastname@example.org or connect with me on Twitter, on Facebook, or on Instagram (szied713).